Is Dyslexia a Visual or Phonological Deficit?

Thursday, February 11, 2010

It's interesting how the public's impression of dyslexia differs from the impressions of researchers in the field. I recently read an article by Vidyasagar and Pammer arguing that dyslexia is a visual deficit. To the general public, this claim seems obvious because most people believe that people with dyslexia see things backwards.



Many dyslexia researchers, however, will find this claim unusual, if not controversial.  This is because the field concluded long ago that the "reading backwards" theory is a myth. As we touched on in a previous article, all children will write backwards to some extent, not just dyslexic children

The current prevailing theory of dyslexia is actually poor auditory or phonological processing. People with dyslexia score lower than controls on phonological awareness, and phonological awareness in children predicts reading skill later on. In addition, some phonological training studies have succeeded in improving reading performance in children with dyslexia.

Vidyasagar and Pammer propose a different theory.  They argue that dyslexia is due to a deficit in visual attention and the dorsal visual stream.

Human vision is processed in two pathways in the brain. The ventral stream processes object identity, and the dorsal stream processes object location. When we read, the dorsal stream helps us direct our attention smoothly from one word to the next. Vidyasagar argues that a deficit in the dorsal stream is the underlying cause for dyslexia.

They cite some evidence for causality. Studies have found that deficits in coherent motion detection and visual contrast sensitivity, both dorsal stream functions, predict future reading skill.

But what about all the phonological results? Vidyasagar argues that  both visual and auditory input are required to develop a good understanding and awareness of phonetics, and that the  phonological deficits in dyslexia arise from a lack of high quality visual input during the time period when phonological awareness is maturing.  It will be up to researchers to conduct comprehensive studies to test this.

So what do I think?  My favorite theory is neither purely phonological nor visual one, but rather another possibility that Vidyasagar touches on – a deficit in rapid sensory processing. Rapid auditory processing is important for phonological awareness, and rapid visual processing is important for visual attention and visual search.  There is evidence that people with dyslexia have deficits in both.

Genetically, the theory makes sense. Genes don’t just code for one function. More often, they code for proteins that show up in multiple systems. You could imagine a gene that codes for some rapid processing neuron that plays a roll in both visual and auditory processing, resulting in the complex disorder we know as dyslexia.

It’s an exiting time to be a brain researcher.

Vidyasagar, T., & Pammer, K. (2010). Dyslexia: a deficit in visuo-spatial attention, not in phonological processing Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 14 (2), 57-63 DOI: 10.1016/j.tics.2009.12.003

3 comments:

Edd February 11, 2010 at 2:25 PM  

I have dyslexia. visual information transmission error could be part of the problem, but sometime it resolve into phoneme confusion. at least in education area there is a whole host of variances that can not be explained in one simple little theory.

Luqman Michel February 18, 2010 at 4:50 AM  

My name is Luqman Michel and I have been teaching dyslexic children successfully for more than 5 years.I find that dyslexics are just very logical thinking people. When something is not logical their mind shuts off.All my students speak and read two languages- Malay and English. Some learn and read 3 languages -Malay, Han Yu Pin Yin (Romanized Mandarin) and English. All of them have no problem reading both Malay and Han Yu Pin Yin. All of them find reading in English difficult.However when I tell them that the English language is not logical like Malay and Han Yu Pin Yin they change their mind set and learn English at a much faster rate.
Visit my weblog that I just started at:
http://www.parentingdyslexia.com
Your comments will be welcome
Thank you and kind regards,
Luqman Michel

Ranjit January 4, 2011 at 11:38 PM  

Dyslexia Group Increase awareness and understanding of the effects of dyslexia ... Bring together those involved with dyslexic adults and children to discuss ways…
the aim to bring about a dyslexia friendly society. We are in England, the Town of Luton. I started the group to aim to encourage organizations and individuals to work together represent the needs of dyslexic people, that we can work together to raise awareness of dyslexia… support all to reach their full potential as audience or members, to take positive action to achieve this. To work with others in the aim to bring about improvements and build a wider group of people the opportunity to do ... meaning to a much wider audience than the individual alone. I'm hopeful that we can make this happen together. It is an open group for the reasons above.

Kindly Join us : http://www.facebook.com/home.php?sk=group_106864549382789&ap=1

Thanks & Regards
Ranjit
Admin

Post a Comment

  © Blogger template The Professional Template II by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP